Thursday, May 2, 2013

Germany’s Nuclear Energy Phaseout: The Timetable


By the end of 2022 Germany will have no nuclear power plants remaining. I have covered why this policy is folly elsewhere, so won’t cover it again here. Instead let us consider in a little detail how things will pan out in the next decade. To put the numbers in perspective I will estimate how much solar power will need to be added to replace the lost production due to each reactor being closed early (assuming a solar panel life span of 25 years and capacity factor of 10%). I’m using solar, not wind because the load factor for wind farms will be quite dependent on how much offshore wind is built, but if you want onshore wind figures just divide by 2.5.
Here’s the timetable of future reactor shutdowns:
2015: 1 reactor closes
Reactor: Grafenrheinfeld, (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 85.8%
Original shut down date: 2028
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.8 GW
2017: 1 reactor closes
Reactor: Gundremmingen-B (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 83.6%
Original shut down date: 2030
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.8 GW
2019: 1 reactor closes
Reactor: Phillipsburg-2 (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 88.3%
Original shut down date: 2032
Solar required to replace lost production: 7.3 GW
2021: 3 reactors close
Reactor: Gundremmingen-C (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 88.3%
Original shut down date: 2030
Solar required to replace lost production: 5 GW
Reactor: Brokdorf (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 88.2%
Original shut down date: 2033
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.7 GW
Reactor: Grohnde (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 90.4%
Original shut down date: 2031
Solar required to replace lost production: 5.6 GW
2022: 3 reactors close
Reactor: Isar-2 (1.4 GW)
Average load factor: 89.5%
Original shut down date: 2034
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.7 GW
Reactor: Emsland (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 93.5%
Original shut down date: 2035
Solar required to replace lost production: 6.8 GW
Reactor: Neckarwestheim-2 (1.3 GW)
Average load factor: 92.3%
Original shut down date: 2036
Solar required to replace lost production: 7.3 GW
Looking Ahead
In total Germany would need to build an additional 59 GW of solar power to replace the lost production of the shuttered nukes. This of course is a rather simplified view. The sun does not shine at 6 pm in Winter when Germany’s electricity demand peaks. And the wind does not always blow either. In fact Germany can probably rely on just a bit above zero wind power, so this lost nuclear production could be made up by building a large number of wind turbines and solar panels. However the lost capacity cannot be, a distinction many fail to recognise. Fossil fuelled (or biomass) power plants will need to be built. To see this consider that Germany has over 30 GW of wind turbines, yet at 6pm on January 14th 2013 barely 0.5 GW, or 1.5% of capacity, was feeding into the grid.

No comments:

Post a Comment